News

WWE Star Suing For Emotional Damage After Sickening Incident

By Lyle Kilbane • Published Jan 07, 2026 09:10 EST
WWE logo Shiloh Hill Arianna Grace

WWE has got off to a wild start for 2026, but one star is threatening a lawsuit after things got a bit too graphic.

2026 might be a week old, but in WWE, already, fans have seen Randy Orton return to SmackDown, Matt Cardona rejoin the company and banish his old Zack Ryder name forever, Becky Lynch win the WWE Women’s Intercontinental Championship, Rhea Ripley and IYO SKY capture tag team gold, and Bron Breakker fall directly on top of his head after a Frankensteiner went very wrong.

But none of that could compare to how gruesome things got at NXT New Year’s Evil.

WWE Star Suffers False Tooth Nightmare

NXT New Year’s Evil saw Tavion Heights and Jasper Troy come face-to-face, surrounded by several NXT stars. Heights warned that he’d defeat Troy to become the NXT Speed Champion before Ethan Page joined them. It wasn’t long before things turned physical as a brawl broke out.

Left in the middle of the ring were the deranged Shiloh Hill and Arianna Grace. Grace went on the attack, but Hill grabbed her hand to dance. As it looked like he was leaning in for a kiss, his false tooth fell out directly onto Grace.

Taking to social media, an irate Arianna Grace threatened legal action for the horrifying moment as she wrote:

Suing for emotional damages!!!! I’m sick to my stomach!