Mariah May Sends Puzzling Message As AEW Future In Doubt

Mariah May has issued her first public comment since reports surfaced putting her AEW future in serious doubt.

At Revolution, Mariah May lost a bloody battle to long-time rival “Timeless” Toni Storm for the AEW Women’s Title. The “Hollywood Ending” capped off a storyline that began when May signed with the company back in November 2023. The British star initially served as Storm’s protégé, but the following May, she turned heel and attacked Storm after winning the Owen Hart Cup.

Mariah May then went on to beat Storm for the AEW Women’s Title at All In, before losing it back to her great rival at Grand Slam Australia in February 2025. But despite the storyline being met with great acclaim, May has been missing ever since she lost her title.

As reported via Fightful Select, many within AEW believe May’s contract is set to expire “in the summer.” While it’s unknown whether any option years are attached to her deal, one source noted they would be incredibly surprised if there aren’t as it’s unlikely May would be pushed so hard while on such a short contract.

Mariah May Cryptic Over AEW Future

Mariah May has now taken to her Instagram Stories to issue her first public comment since rumours about her future surfaced, remaining somewhat cryptic as she wrote:

You can’t make the wrong decision because every decision leads you to where you’re supposed to be

The post was also accompanied by a photo of May tagged with the location Orlando, Florida. Wrestling fans won’t need to be reminded that Orlando is the home of the WWE Performance Center but there is no indication that’s why May is there.